Adjective Clauses: Dropping Joining Words

5
 
 
Grammar name (English): 
Adjective Clause, Relative Clause, Adjectival Clause
Grammar name (日本語): 
関係詞節

When you can drop joining words with adjective clauses.

Adjective clauses are phrases that can identify or describe a thing, place or person. They are a phrase that comes after a noun. They tell us more about that noun. For example:

"the person who lives next door"; or
"the time that we went to Disneyland".

To review, read the introduction to adjective clauses. You should also read about the two main types of adjective clause.

When you can drop joining words

Remember that we use a joining word to connect a noun to the adjective phrase:

  1. "the place where James was born";
  2. "the people that we met on vacation";
  3. "the souvenirs which Ben and Claire bought". 

These joining words can be left out. We sometimes cut the joining words in spoken English and in informal writing:

  1. "the place James was born";
  2. "the people we met on vacation";
  3. "the souvenirs Ben and Claire bought".

This is not always possible.

To understand this next point, you need to know about identifying and describing adjective clauses. Let's review quickly:

  1. A "describing clause" tells us more about something or someone;
  2. An "identifying clause" identifies something or someone.

A describing clause is not needed in a sentence (the information it gives us is a nice bonus), but an identifying clause is important and cannot be cut from the sentence:

  1. Naoto likes to watch True Blood, which is a show about vampires
  2. What is the name of the TV show that you like?

We use identifying clauses when we want to be more specific. Often it is because we don't know the name of something or someone (like in the example above where we want to know the name of the TV show). We use a describing clause when we want to be more helpful. The information in the describing clause is an extra thought.

You can only leave the joining words out of an identifying clause (type 2 above), if there is a subject in the clause. You must use the joining word when you use a describing clause. Here are some examples:

  With joining words Without joining words  
1. Describing Clauses Naoto likes to watch True Blood, which is a show about vampires. NOT: Naoto likes to watch True Blood, is a show about vampires. You must use a joining word.
Naoto, who works for a Swiss company, studied English in Australia. NOT: Naoto, works for a Swiss company, studied English in Australia.
Kazusa-Ichinomiya, where I used to live, is near the sea. NOT: Kazusa-Ichinomiya, I used to live, is near the sea.
2. Identifying Clauses What is the name of that TV show that you like? OR: What is the name of that TV show you like? With or without the joining word is OK.
That's the restaurant where we often eat. OR: That's the restaurant we often eat at.
A person who Sam knows will meet us at the airport. OR:  A person Sam knows will meet us at the airport.
We'll never forget the day when the aliens came. OR: We'll never forget the day the aliens came.
You can ask me any time that you have a question. OR: You can ask me any time you have a question.
The reason why the boss fired him is none of your business. OR: The reason the boss fired him is none of your business.
Can you believe the way that he spoke to me? OR: Can you believe the way he spoke to me?
I am looking for a place where my friend can stay. OR: I am looking for a place my friend can stay.
Notes: 

Note: Dropping the joining words has a couple of really difficult points to it.

  1. There has to be a subject in the adjective clause if you want to drop the joining word.
    - What is the name of that TV show that you like?
    You cannot drop the joining word from sentences that have adjective clauses like these:
    - People who are good at music are good at languages.
    - Fish that fly are called flying fish.
    When you learned about adjective clauses before, you learned that "who", "which" and "that" are special. They can be the subject or object of a verb in a clause. That means that if you cut "who" or "that" in the sentences above, the result is no good. Look:
    - People are good at music are good at languages.
    - Fish fly are called flying fish.
    "Fish fly... are called"? "People are... are"? Two verbs like this, without a joining word to break the sentence up, are hard to understand.
  2. Using "where" is difficult and you might need to add a preposition to your sentence ("at"). Look at the example above without a preposition: "That's the restaurant we often eat." It sounds like we eat restaurants. Actually, we eat at restaurants. The information about location that we get from the word "where" is lost when we cut it. We need to add some information about location (a preposition).

It is hard to think about these points while you speak, but if you make a mistake, now you know why!